
President Trump sat down face-to-face with Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping in a historic summit meant to push toward ending the Ukraine war, and within hours a German chancellor was trashing it as empty theater.
Story Snapshot
- Trump, Putin, and Xi met for about 90 minutes in Shenzhen on November 19 and issued a joint “Declaration toward Peace.”
- German Chancellor Friedrich Merz called the summit “a photo op” and rejected any “Yalta-style” deal that cuts out Europe and Ukraine.
- Trump defended the direct talks, saying “no peace is ever achieved by shunning opportunities for dialogue.”
- Putin said Russia invited European leaders to Moscow, acknowledging Europe wants a seat at the table.
- Ukraine’s European allies gathered in Berlin the same day and vowed new talks, including Europe, would come “soon.”
Trump Sits Down With Putin and Xi in Shenzhen
President Trump, Russian President Vladimir Putin, and Chinese leader Xi Jinping met at a lakeside venue in Shenzhen on November 19 for roughly 90 minutes. The three leaders released a joint “Declaration toward Peace” afterward. The document focused on strategic stability, energy cooperation, and talks on cutting nuclear risk, rather than laying out a detailed settlement for Ukraine.
Trump called the sit-down a historic moment for diplomacy. He pushed back hard against critics who think talking to rivals is a weakness, not a strength. “No peace is ever achieved by shunning opportunities for dialogue,” Trump said, adding that he believed Putin and Ukraine both want the war to end soon.
Merz Dismisses the Summit as a Photo Op
German Chancellor Friedrich Merz wasted no time tearing into the meeting. Speaking in Berlin after a gathering of Ukraine’s allies, Merz called the Shenzhen summit “simply an opportunity for a photo session” and said real peace deals for Ukraine cannot happen without Europe and Kyiv in the room. He also took a shot at any comparison to the 1945 Yalta Conference, where major powers carved up postwar Europe without smaller nations present.
“A ‘Yalta’ format will not bring peace,” Merz told reporters, warning that European leaders would “not allow” the continent to be divided up by outside powers again. Standing alongside allies in Berlin, Merz and other leaders issued a joint statement using nearly identical language, insisting Russia cannot simply outlast Western support for Ukraine.
Putin and Xi Push Back on the Criticism
Putin and Xi offered a very different take on the summit’s value. Putin said Russia, China, and the United States share “converging interests” when it comes to resolving regional conflicts, including Ukraine, and framed the meeting as a shared responsibility among major powers for global stability. Xi echoed that view, describing the three countries as having a common outlook on protecting world peace.
Putin also addressed the European complaints directly. He acknowledged that European nations want a role in any settlement and said Russia had invited European leaders to Moscow for further talks, while still ruling out any military role for Europe tied to Ukraine. That olive branch, paired with Merz’s blistering public criticism, shows just how far apart Washington’s allies remain on how peace talks should actually work.
European Allies Demand a Seat at the Table
France’s Emmanuel Macron joined Merz in downplaying the summit, saying it would not “lead to a reorganisation of the world” on its own. Leaders from Germany, France, Britain, and Ukraine met in Berlin the same day the Shenzhen summit wrapped, issuing their own joint statement rejecting any carve-up of Europe without their input and promising broader talks would follow soon.
Europe’s frustration is understandable, but it also exposes a hard truth: years of talk from Brussels and Berlin have not ended the war. Trump’s willingness to sit across from Putin and Xi directly, without waiting for European consensus, reflects the same America First instinct that has defined his foreign policy, dealing from strength instead of waiting on committees. Whether that approach produces a lasting settlement for Ukraine remains to be seen, but it is already forcing allies to show their cards.
Sources:
kyivpost.com, fidelity.com, nampa.org, dw.com, news.liga.net













